[Reader Mail] . . .
Published 3/22/2007
12:01:34 AM . .
.
AMERICAN CASSANDRA
Re:
Laurie Mylroie's What Is Khalid
Sheikh Mohammed Saying?:
Former
-- Tim O'Neill
[Reader Mail] . . . Published 3/20/2007
12:01:03 AM
WAR OF THE WORDS
Re:
Laurie Mylroie's What Is Khalid
Sheikh Mohammed Saying?:
Ms. Mylroie is persuasive. Readers familiar
with her books and able to appreciate the breadth and profundity of her
knowledge of the Islamic world know well the meticulous, detailed evidence
supporting her view of the nature of our enemy. Odd, isn't it, that she's got to
adduce such a torrent of argument to persuade us of a simpler, more parsimonious
account than the one we've bought into willy-nilly.
That would be the
Vast Islamic Wing Conspiracy theory, the one requiring us to believe in all
sorts of entities and, well, djinns that have never before existed. The
conception of the enemy we cling to, refusing to revoke our suspension of
disbelief.
The conventional view of Al Qaeda is endothermic. Very much
so. We're burning a lot of fuel propping that view up with all sorts of Rube
Goldberg conceptual devices. I'm surprised the Greens haven't condemned it as a
contributor to climate change. Why don't we all just relax, chill, and keep it
simple? Laurie Mylroie is asking us to remember that there's nothing new under
the sun. She's got parsimony on her side.
-- Paul Kotik
Plantation,